Surprise? Offering In Class Breakfasts of Cereal, Muffins, Juice, Increases Obesity

Those are the results of a study recently published in JAMA Pediatrics, and really, they don't seem all that surprising.

Firstly, the breakfasts were offered to all children, regardless of whether this was, as Hobbits might say, second breakfast.

But more to the point, would anyone expect a not likely to be sating breakfast consisting of cereal, muffin, juice, and milk, to have a positive impact on weight or health (and I should take the time here to point out that the study authors were not in charge of what schools chose to feed their students)?

As I've ranted many times, what a person eats for breakfast likely matters a great deal to satiety, health, weight and what have you. I've also ranted on the dangers of lumping studies of specific meals (in this case ultra-processed carbs washed down with a bunch of liquid calories) and then opining on the benefits of "breakfast" as a meal.

Food insecurity is real, and finding the means to ensure children eat healthy meals is laudable, but feeding children who are already at increased risk of chronic diseases, meals that may themselves increase the risk of developing chronic diseases, probably isn't in their best interest, and given that, as one of the study's authors Kate Bauer noted on Twitter,

"all breakfasts met the federal School Breakfast Program requirements"

it sure makes one wonder whether America's federal School Breakfast Program could stand for some revision? 

 

Author
Yoni Freedhoff, MD

You Might Also Enjoy...

Get Better at Dealing with Anger

Yesterday a loved one asked me about dealing with anger — he lashed out at someone he loves in a way that hurt her and filled him with shame and regret.

What It’s Like to Be Truly Committed to Something

All my life, I’ve struggled with being half-committed. Not always, but more than I’d usually like to admit. I say I’m going to stick to something, and I actually believe it, but then a week later (or sooner, sometimes longer), I falter. I justify it.

Start Your Day Right with the Magic Morning Mindset

We would likely all agree that manicures, baths, and cozy movie nights on the couch all fall under the umbrella of self-care. But I believe that it’s time—actually, beyond time—to go deeper and re-claim what self-care truly means.

When Someone You Love Is Grieving: How to Really Help

There’s the awkwardness. You always feel a little like an uninvited guest who arrived late and missed the first half of the conversation—a conversation that turns out to be a wrestle between another person and the deepest parts of their own soul.